0
Skip to Content
Forgotten Tonic
Menu
Private Events
Gift Cards
Careers
Team
Location
Contact
Reservations
Forgotten Tonic
Menu
Private Events
Gift Cards
Careers
Team
Location
Contact
Reservations
Menu
Private Events
Gift Cards
Careers
Team
Location
Contact
Reservations
MIRACLE MENU COCKTAILS
$18
Christmapolitan
vodka, elderflower, dry vermouth, spiced cranberry sauce, lime, rosemary, absinthe mist
$18
$18
Snowball Old-Fashioned
rye whiskey, gingerbread, aromatic & wormwood bitters, orange essence
$18
$23
Sugarplum Stampede
Irish whiskey, amontillado sherry, apricot, dark crème de cacao, lemon, miso honey, figgy bitters
$23
$18
Christmas Cricket
blanco tequila, vanilla liqueur, minty amaro, coco pandan, cream, mole bitters
$18
$16
Koala LaLaLa
blanco tequila, dry vermouth, apple liqueur, tamarind, lemon, eucalyptus bitters, mint, soda
$16
$23
Sleigh-Saurus
peanut butter whiskey, dark rum, velvet falernum, French bitter, black sesame, oat milk, lemon, nutmeg
$23
$20
Run Run Reindeer
mulled wine reduction, prosecco, lemon, aromatic bitters
$20
$18
Run Run Reindeer
mulled wine reduction, prosecco, lemon, aromatic bitters
$18
$23
Rudolph's Replacement
vodka, coffee liqueur, white crème de cacao, orange curaçao, chai, oat milk, aromatic bitters
$23
$23
Merry Mouse-Tail
white rum, cognac, Madeira, mandarin, clove, lemon, aromatic bitters
$23
$15
Jingle Balls Nog
cognac, cream sherry, oat milk, cream, egg, vanilla, nutmeg
$15
$15
Mulled Wine
**served hot** mulled red wine, tawny port, orange liqueur, Christmas spices
$15
$24
The Krampus
reposado tequila, oloroso sherry, allspice dram, mezcal, ginger, hibiscus, lime, hellfire bitters
$24
$18
Secret Santa
pickle beer, bloody mary mix, lime juice, spiced pepper shrub, maggi seasoning
$18
SPIRIT-FREE COCKTAILS
$12
Ginger Bell Rock
mandarin, clove, ginger, lime, tonic
$12
$12
Tinsel & Tart
verjus rouge, cranberry, orange, lemon, Christmas spices
$12
SHOTS
$9
NICE SHOT
whiskey, spiced ginger, lemon acid
$9
$9
NAUGHTY SHOT
tequila, habanero, ginger, hibiscus, lime acid
$9
APPETIZERS
$14
Queso Frito
Fried queso blanco, port poached pear, pineapple relish, guava hot honey, drop peppers, crostini
$14
$17
Crab Cake Arancini
Crispy arancini, crab, Old Bay rémoulade, crispy onion & parsley
$17
add an arancini +6
$16
Cajun Egg Rolls
Crispy egg rolls, blackened chicken, cream cheese, cabbage, black beans, spicy ranch
$16
add additional egg roll +8
$10
Warm Bread
Toasted focaccia, whipped garlic butter or cinnamon-datil honey butter
$10
dairy free option +1
$18
Fried Chicken Bao
Crispy chicken, kimchi slaw, Korean pickled cucumber, honey-soy sauce & Thai chili aioli
$18
$13
Chef's Pickle Selection
Chef’s assortment of ferments and house pickles
$13
add crostini +2
$15
Black Bean Hummus
Black bean & chickpea hummus, corn salsa, cilantro-lime oil, chili dusted wonton chips, crudités
$15
sub extra crudités for wonton chips +2
$13
Bruschetta
Roasted grape tomatoes, garlic seasoned toast, whipped burrata, basil, balsamic reduction
$13
add prosciutto +7
FOR THE TABLE
$13
Brussels Sprouts
Roasted Brussels sprouts, smoky gochujang BBQ, maple syrup
$13
$13
Honeynut Squash Hash
Roasted honeynut squash, onion, bell pepper, garlic, maple brown butter, candied pecans
$13
$13
Kimchi Fried Rice
Crispy rice, gochujang aioli, seasonal kimchi, garlic, ginger, serrano, black garlic-soy honey, furikake
$13
add fried chicken breast +10
$11
Four Cheese Grits
Stone-ground grits, Havarti, Parmesan, Asiago, Romano, green onion
$11
$13
Risotto
Creamy risotto, butter, Parmesan & fresh herbs
$13
$10
French Fries
Seasoned fries, roasted garlic aioli & sweet tomato purée
$10
trufflize it +3
SOUP & SALAD
$12
Cajun Chowder
Chicken, andouille & gator sausage, bacon, roasted corn, potato, creamy Cajun broth, crispy onion & lemon zest
$12
Half 11 / Whole 20
Caesar Salad
Romaine, garlic croutons, Parmesan, anchovy, Caesar dressing, black pepper
Half 11 / Whole 20
add grilled chicken breast +10
$15
Roasted Squash Salad
Roasted honeynut squash, arugula, maple-Dijon vinaigrette, pickled squash & pear, pepita brittle, blue cheese & crispy squash ribbons
$15
LITTLE ELVES
$9
I Don't Want That
Pasta sautéed with Parmesan and garlic
$9
add grilled chicken breast +10
$12
I Don't Know
Fried chicken tenders with french fries.
$12
$12
I Don't Care
Hamburger on a pretzel bun with french fries.
$12
add havarti cheese +2
SANDWICHES
$22
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken, drop pepper pimento cheese, arugula, fried pickled green tomato, crispy onion & poblano ranch, garlic-buttered pretzel bun, French fries
$22
substitute fried chicken +1
$22
FT Burger
Beef, Havarti, bacon, caramelized onion, pickles, FT sauce, pretzel bun, fries
$22
add blue cheese +3
trufflize the fries +3
$29
Steak Sandwich
Chopped sirloin, roasted poblano, caramelized onion, bell pepper, mushroom, Havarti, black pepper aioli, baguette, fries
$29
$23
Fish Sandwich
Miso-marinated cod, black garlic-miso aioli, citrus slaw, furikake, toasted ciabatta, Brussels sprouts
$23
MAINS
$26
Coconut Curry
Red coconut curry, fried tofu, bell pepper, poblano, carrot, red onion, lemongrass, ginger, seasoned jasmine rice
$26
substitute shrimp for tofu +2
$29
Sautéed Mussels
Blue mussels, white wine, fennel, roasted onion, garlic, chorizo, tomato, seafood broth, focaccia
$29
$22
Pasta Alla Vodka
Cavatappi, green chile vodka sauce, Parmesan, toasted breadcrumbs, herb oil, whipped burrata & fried basil
$22
add grilled chicken breast +10
$33
Chicken Bella
Confit half chicken, honeynut squash hash, sage brown-butter jus & verjus gastrique
$33
$28
Shrimp & Grits Étouffée
Blackened shrimp, four-cheese grits, andouille étouffée, green onion & fried jalapeño
$28
MP
Chef's Cut
Today’s featured cut with a seasonal preparation and side. Ask your server for details
MP
$45
Scallop Scampi
Seared scallops, fried grit cake, garlic scampi butter, Parmesan, parsley, garlic toast
$45
MP
Fresh Catch
Today’s fresh fish with the chef’s seasonal accompaniment. Ask your server for today’s preparation
MP
$34
Wild Mushroom & Duck Gnocchi
Crispy gnocchi, smoked duck breast, wild mushroom-cognac cream, Parmesan, sage, orange, pickled mustard seed
$34
DESSERT
$12
Sticky Toffee Pudding
Warm date pudding, spiced-rum apricot & cranberry, toffee sauce, almond Chantilly & almond brittle
$12
$12
Eggnog Crème Brûlée
Eggnog custard, caramelized sugar, spiced whipped cream, gingerbread tuile & gingerbread crumbs
$12
$16
Hazelnut Cheesecake
Hazelnut cheesecake, Nutella ganache, orange zest, vanilla crème fraîche whip, orange sauce & flaky sea salt
$16
$14
Almond-Orange Date Cake
Almond-orange date cake, cranberry-orange compote, vanilla bean buttercream, candied cranberries, orange zest & powdered sugar
$14
$9
Hot Cocoa
Chocolate, cocoa powder, heavy cream, vanilla, marshmallow
$9

PDF MENU

Forgotten Tonic Miracle Menu PDF Menu 2026

Reservations

HOURS

Monday 11am - 11pm
Tuesday 11am - 11pm
Wednesday 11am - 11pm
Thursday 11am - 11pm
Friday 11am - 12am
Saturday 11am - 12am
Sunday 11am - 11pm

We stop seating for dinner service one hour before closing, with cocktail service available until close.

We are closed 1/28, 7/8, 11/18, Thanksgiving & Christmas Day

ADDRESS

6 Aviles St
St. Augustine, FL 32084

PHONE

(904) 827-9055


EMAIL

info@forgottentonic.com