0
Skip to Content
Forgotten Tonic
Menu
Private Events
Gift Cards
Careers
Team
Location
Contact
Reservations
Forgotten Tonic
Menu
Private Events
Gift Cards
Careers
Team
Location
Contact
Reservations
Menu
Private Events
Gift Cards
Careers
Team
Location
Contact
Reservations
MIRACLE MENU COCKTAILS
$18
CHRISTMAPOLITAN
vodka, elderflower, dry vermouth, spiced cranberry sauce, lime, rosemary, absinthe mist
$18
$18
SNOWBALL OLD-FASHIONED
rye whiskey, gingerbread, aromatic & wormwood bitters, orange essence
$18
$22
CANDY CANE LANE
white rum, vanilla liqueur, dark crème de cacao, minty amaro, candy cane, oat milk
$22
$18
DANCING SUGARPLUMS
gin, limoncello, plum wine, plum milk syrup, lemon, tiki bitters, nutmeg
$18
$16
KOALA LALALA
blanco tequila, dry vermouth, apple liqueur, tamarind, lemon, eucalyptus bitters, mint, soda
$16
$22
CHEERY CHERRY CHOCOSAURUS
brandy, italian sweet vermouth, dark crème de cacao, blackberry liqueur, tart cherry & chocolate, lemon, chocolate bitters, brandied cherries
$22
$20
BLITZEN BARREL
cream sherry, mead, scotch, PX sherry, honey, sesame
$20
$18
RUN RUN REINDEER
mulled wine reduction, prosecco, lemon, aromatic bitters
$18
$20
YIPPEE KI YAY MOTHER F*****R!
barbados rum, rhum agricole, trinidad overproof rum, ube & coconut orgeat, acid-adjusted pineapple juice
$20
$22
RUDOLPH'S REPLACEMENT
vodka, coffee liqueur, white creme de cacao, orange curaçao, chai syrup, almond milk, aromatic bitters
$22
$22
THE KRAMPUS
reposado tequila, oloroso sherry, allspice dram, mezcal, ginger, hibiscus, lime, hellfire bitters
$22
$22
MIRACLE MOUSE
bourbon, french sweet vermouth, pamplemousse liqueur, vanilla liqueur, strawberry, grapefruit, orange acid
$22
$15
JINGLE BALLS NOG
cognac, cream sherry, almond milk, cream, egg, vanilla, nutmeg
$15
$15
COCONUT HOT CHOCOLATE
**served hot** aged jamaican rum, amaretto, chocolate, hazelnut & coconut, coconut whipped cream, cacao dust
$15
$16
CAROL SINGER
**served hot** apple cider, white wine, peach liqueur, pear liqueur, apple brandy, orange, ginger, christmas spices
$16
$16
MULLED WINE
**served hot** mulled red wine, tawny port, orange liqueur, christmas spices
$16
NON-ALCOHOLIC COCKTAILS
$12
SNOW DAY SIPPER
**served hot** chocolate hazelnut and coconut syrup, coconut whipped cream, cacao dust
$12
$12
SILENT NIGHT
tart cherry, chocolate, orange acid, soda
$12
$12
MELLOW MOUSE
apple, strawberry, grapefruit, lemon, soda
$12
SHOTS
$10
NICE SHOT
brandy, strawberry, grapefruit
$10
$10
NAUGHTY SHOT
tequila, habanero, ginger, hibiscus
$10
APPETIZERS
$10
WARM BREAD
Soft, oven-warmed focaccia served with a whipped cinnamon–datil honey compound butter.
$10
dairy free option +1
MONTENEGRO MEATBALLS
Ground beef meatballs infused with Amaro Montenegro and exotic spices, mixed with almonds and onions, served over a rich herbed cream sauce and garnished with parsley. 15
BRUSCHETTA
Oven-roasted grape tomatoes and garlic atop thick-cut toast, with melted mozzarella, basil chiffonade, and a balsamic reduction. 13
$11
PICKLE PLATE
A tangy assortment featuring Grandpa Hausman’s icebox pickles, apple fennel kimchi, pimentos, pickled cranberries and red onion served with dijon mustard and capers.
$11
add toasted bread +3
CHARCUTERIE BOARD
Chef’s selection of cured meats & cheeses accompanied by toasted bread, cornichons pickles, olives, and capers. MP
$19
TUNA TARTARE
Diced sushi-grade ahi tuna tossed with strawberries, jalapeño, shaved carrots, green and red onions in a bright strawberry ponzu dressing and a sprinkle of furikake.
$19
$12
SMOKED FISH DIP
Blackened smoked fish folded into a creamy blend of Old Bay, lemon, dill, and Tabasco. Finished with crispy onions, lemon zest, and fresh dill. Served chilled with crostini and seasonal vegetables.
$12
$15
CRISPY ARTICHOKE
A playful twist on spinach artichoke dip, with cornstarch candied artichoke hearts deep-fried to crispy perfection, served with a herbed cheese spinach dipping sauce, and topped with a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese.
$15
$11
CRANBERRY PECAN HUMMUS
Creamy chickpea hummus blended with toasted pecans and tart cranberries, finished with a drizzle of orange-infused oil. Garnished with cranberries and crushed pecans. Served with crisp apples, crudités, and toasted bread for dipping.
$11
no bread, crudités only +1
$20
BAKED BRIE
Creamy brie wrapped in golden puff pastry with apple pie compote, topped with apple molasses marmalade and pistachio almond crumble. Served warm with fresh fruit and toast points.
$20
$16
CAJUN EGG ROLLS
Crispy egg rolls filled with blackened chicken, cream cheese, chili paste, cabbage & black beans, served with a bold spicy ranch sauce for dipping.
$16
add additional egg roll +9
$15
ARANCINI
Crispy risotto balls filled with rich mushroom duxelles, coated in Parmesan breadcrumbs, and fried until golden, served over a creamy herbed vodka sauce.
$15
$9
PIMENTO CHEESE TARTINE
Pimento cheese piled on toasted bread, topped with crispy prosciutto, juicy grape tomatoes, and fresh green onions, drizzled with datil pepper infused honey.
$9
SOUP & SALAD
$11
ALLIGATOR CHILI
A Southern-style chili made with tender alligator, black-eyed peas, and kidney beans, simmered in a rich, seasoned sauce. Finished with a smooth sweet corn crema, roasted corn, and crunchies.
$11
Half 11 / Whole 20
FT HOUSE SALAD
Vibrant mix of leafy greens, cucumber, tomatoes, red onion, gorgonzola, dried cranberries & shaved carrots. Tossed in a rich balsamic vinaigrette.
Half 11 / Whole 20
add grilled shrimp +12
Half 11 / Whole 20
CAESAR SALAD
Crisp romaine hearts with garlic croutons, shaved Parmesan, anchovy fillets, and creamy Caesar dressing, finished with freshly ground black pepper.
Half 11 / Whole 20
add blackened chicken thigh +10
Half 12 / Whole 22
HARVEST BRUSSELS SALAD
Shaved Brussels sprouts and kale with crisp apples, aged gouda, and pomegranate arils, all tossed in a toasted pistachio vinaigrette. Finished with orange zest, crushed pistachios, and a touch of black pepper.
Half 12 / Whole 22
add crispy tofu +8
KIDS
$9
I DON’T WANT THAT
Pasta sauteed with parmesan and garlic.
$9
add grilled chicken thigh +10
$9
I’M NOT HUNGRY
Cuban bread topped with cheese and cream sauce and baked golden.
$9
add bacon +3
$12
I DON’T KNOW
Fried chicken tenders with french fries.
$12
$12
I DON’T CARE
Hamburger on a pretzel bun with french fries.
$12
add havarti cheese +2
SIDES
$11
FRENCH FRIES
Seasoned french fries with roasted garlic aioli and sweetened & puréed tomatoes.
$11
trufflize it +3
$13
STIR FRY ANCIENT RICE
Stir-fried white rice with crisp carrots, green onions, and tender spinach, tossed in a savory-sweet Korean BBQ sauce.
$13
$11
FOUR CHEESE GRITS
Creamy stone-ground grits blended with a rich quartet of havarti, parmesan, asiago & romano cheeses, finished with green onion.
$11
$13
BRUSSELS SPROUTS
Roasted Brussels sprouts tossed in a smoky gochujang BBQ glaze with a touch of maple sweetness.
$13
$13
PATATAS BRAVAS
White wine–poached potatoes, fried until golden and tossed in garlic–sage aioli.
$13
$13
SWEET POTATO HASH
Roasted sweet potatoes tossed with sautéed onions, Brussels sprouts, kale, bell peppers, garlic, and fresh herbs, finished with miso brown butter and a sprinkle of toasted pumpkin seeds.
$13
$11
MASHED POTATOES
Creamy Yukon Gold potatoes blended with roasted garlic, thyme-infused cream, and melted butter, finished with and a touch of white pepper.
$11
trufflize it +3
$13
RISOTTO
Creamy Arborio rice slowly simmered in rich chicken stock, finished with butter, Parmesan cheese, and a touch of cream.
$13
MAINS
FISH SANDWICH
Grilled or blackened redfish topped with crisp leafy greens, sliced tomato & red onion on cuban bread. Dressed with dill tartar sauce and a side of crispy French fries. 23
$19
CHICKEN SANDWICH
Roasted chicken thigh on a warm pretzel bun with pickled red onions and dill pickle chips, topped with creamy pimento cheese and arugula. Finished with a drizzle of datil infused honey and a side of crispy French fries.
$19
$19
FT BURGER
Juicy ground beef topped with melted havarti, caramelized onions, bacon & pickles. Dressed with FT sauce on a warm pretzel bun, accompanied by french fries.
$19
$35
STEAK SANDWICH
Grilled steak, thinly sliced on a toasted Cuban roll, layered with blue cheese dressing, arugula, and tangy pickled red onions. Finished with crumbled blue cheese and a drizzle of balsamic-fig glaze. Served with a side of crispy fries.
$35
$19
BANH MI
Crispy tofu marinated in soy, ginger, and porcini, layered with pickled carrots, onions, cucumbers, and fresh cilantro on toasted Cuban bread. Finished with our zesty cilantro-chile aioli and jalapenos.
$19
$18
BURRATA SANDWICH
Creamy burrata layered with sage walnut pesto, thick-cut tomato, and fragrant basil leaves on toasted focaccia. Served with french fries.
$18
add prosciutto +8
MP
FRESH CATCH
Seasonal catch paired with the chef’s handpicked side. Ask your server for today’s fresh selection and details.
MP
$20
BIBIMBAP
Vibrant mix of sesame-roasted seasonal vegetables & mushrooms paired with steamed seasoned white rice. Generously topped with spicy Korean chili sauce and a sprinkle of furikake and a side of apple kimchi.
$20
add crispy tofu +8
SHRIMP & GRITS ÉTOUFFÉE
Blackened east coast shrimp over creamy cheese grits, surrounded by a rich andouille sausage étouffée. Finished with green onion and jalapeño. 28
$33
CHICKEN BELLA
Confit half chicken, crisp-skinned and tender, served with a warm sweet potato hash with shaved Brussels sprouts and wilted kale, finished with a silky fig port gastrique.
$33
$21
PASTA ALLA VODKA
Simmered carrots, onions & garlic pureed in vegetable stock, infused with spicy green chile & tossed with cavatappi pasta. Garnished with aged Parmesan, basil leaves, toasted bread crumbs, and a drizzle of herb oil.
$21
add grilled chicken thigh +10
MP
CHEF'S CUT
Chef’s choice of cut & preparation with a seasonally inspired side.
MP
$29
SAUTEED MUSSELS
Blue mussels steamed in a savory broth of white wine, fennel, roasted onions, garlic, chorizo, seafood stock, and fire-roasted tomatoes. Served with thick-cut focaccia.
$29
MEATLOAF
A rich blend of pork and Wagyu beef, served over creamy roasted garlic mashed potatoes. Finished with a velvety sage & veal demi-glace and crowned with a nest of fried maple-shredded carrots. 39
DESSERT
$11
MASALA CHAI CHEESECAKE
A creamy chai-infused cheesecake baked on a buttery pecan sandie crust, layered with warm notes of spice and sweetness. Served with a cloud of maple mascarpone cream and finished with a delicate drizzle of chai syrup.
$11
$11
CHOCOLATE SALAMI
Rich dark chocolate studded with pecans, almonds, pistachios, and crushed graham crackers, rolled and sliced like a classic Italian salami. Finished with a dusting of powdered sugar, the reason your girl left you.
$11
$9
CHIA SEED PUDDING
Chia seeds hydrated with coconut water, infused with vanilla and coconut extract, and lightly sweetened, topped with granola and a spritz of navy strength Jamaican rum.
$9
$13
BUTTER SPICED RUM CAKE
A moist, buttery spiced rum cake cooked in warm rum syrup, served with a pineapple compote and finished with toasted coconut.
$13
$11
HOT CHOCOLATE CRÈME BRÛLÉE
A rich & velvety hot chocolate infused custard with a caramelized sugar crust. Topped with toasted marshmallows and a dusting of powdered sugar for a nostalgic campfire sweetness.
$11
$11
UBE TIRAMISU
A vibrant twist on the classic Italian dessert, layers of cold brew–soaked ladyfingers enveloped in a silky ube infused mascarpone cream. Finished with a dusting of sweet ube powder and toasted coconut flakes.
$11

PDF MENU

Forgotten Tonic Miracle Menu PDF Menu 2025

HOURS

Monday 11am - 11pm
Tuesday 11am - 11pm
Wednesday 11am - 11pm
Thursday 11am - 11pm
Friday 11am - 12am
Saturday 11am - 12am
Sunday 11am - 11pm

Holiday Hours:
Thanksgiving & Christmas Day - Closed

ADDRESS

6 Aviles St
St. Augustine, FL 32084

PHONE

(904) 827-9055


EMAIL

info@forgottentonic.com

Reservations